Gemstone Engagement Rings

Shop gemstone engagement rings handcrafted in New York City. Not every love story is told in diamonds. Our gemstone engagement rings feature natural sapphires, rubies, emeralds, and more — each with its own meaning, personality, and brilliance. Handcrafted by master jewelers in our NYC workshop.

Shop by Gemstone

Sapphire Engagement Rings — Royal blue and delicate pink; 9 Mohs hardness. Perfect for daily wear.

Ruby Engagement Rings — Bold, passionate red; symbolizes love and courage.

Emerald Engagement Rings — Lush green; the stone of rebirth and new beginnings.

Why Choose a Gemstone Engagement Ring?

Gemstone rings offer color, personality, and meaning that diamonds alone can't provide. They're often more affordable than comparable-quality diamonds, more unique, and deeply personal. Many brides choose a gemstone that matches a birthstone, heritage symbol, or simply a color they love.

Shop All Engagement Rings

All Engagement Rings | Diamond Engagement Rings | Vintage Rings | Celtic Rings

Availability
Price
$
-
$
179 Items
Sort By

Filters

Availability
Price
$
-
$
New Orleans Three Stone Engagement Ring25% off

New Orleans Three Stone Engagement Ring

$4,457.00From $3,343.00
Save$1,114.00
Minneapolis Three Stone Engagement Ring25% off

Minneapolis Three Stone Engagement Ring

$2,955.00From $2,216.00
Save$739.00
Kansas City Three Stone Engagement Ring25% off

Kansas City Three Stone Engagement Ring

$3,845.00From $2,884.00
Save$961.00
Pittsburgh Three Stone Engagement Ring25% off

Pittsburgh Three Stone Engagement Ring

$2,165.00From $1,624.00
Save$541.00
Hialeah Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Scottsdale Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off

Scottsdale Sidestone Engagement Ring

$2,134.00From $1,601.00
Save$533.00
Newark Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Irving Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Tampa Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Oakland Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Newcastle Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Perth Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off
Albury Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off

Albury Sidestone Engagement Ring

$1,303.00From $977.00
Save$326.00
Darwin Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off

Darwin Sidestone Engagement Ring

$2,139.00From $1,604.00
Save$535.00
Sydney Sidestone Engagement Ring25% off

Shop gemstone engagement rings handcrafted in New York City. Not every love story is told in diamonds. Our gemstone engagement rings feature natural sapphires, rubies, emeralds, and more — each with its own meaning, personality, and brilliance. Handcrafted by master jewelers in our NYC workshop.

Shop by Gemstone

Sapphire Engagement Rings — Royal blue and delicate pink; 9 Mohs hardness. Perfect for daily wear.

Ruby Engagement Rings — Bold, passionate red; symbolizes love and courage.

Emerald Engagement Rings — Lush green; the stone of rebirth and new beginnings.

Why Choose a Gemstone Engagement Ring?

Gemstone rings offer color, personality, and meaning that diamonds alone can't provide. They're often more affordable than comparable-quality diamonds, more unique, and deeply personal. Many brides choose a gemstone that matches a birthstone, heritage symbol, or simply a color they love.

Shop All Engagement Rings

All Engagement Rings | Diamond Engagement Rings | Vintage Rings | Celtic Rings

Faq

Every band is solid 14K gold throughout — never plated, never filled. Each ring is hallmarked 585 and ships with a signed certificate of authenticity.